Which 'PLL' Star Wore Black Lipstick Best?

Looks like both Ashley Benson and Troian Bellisario have been in a particularly gothic mood lately, both sporting incredibly hard to pull off black lipstick.

Ashley was first to show off the dramatic look on her Instagram a month ago, rocking some heavy black eyeliner to match. But her Pretty Little Liars co-star Troian actually dared to wear the look on the red carpet Tuesday night at a screening of this season's Pretty Little Liars Halloween episode at Hollywood Forever Cemetery, also playing up her eyes with multiple coats of thick black mascara.

Pics: Could You Pull Off These Celebrity Trends?

But what do you think? Is this look actually wearable, or should it be strictly saved for Halloween?