EXCLUSIVE: Director Richard Kelly and Jake Gyllenhaal on Why 'Donnie Darko' Still Resonates Today

By

On Oct. 26, 2001, Donnie
Darko
, director Richard Kelly’s sci-fi film about a despondent teenager
(Jake Gyllenhaal in his second major film role) who befriends a giant bunny
named Frank (James Duval), was released in theaters. The film told a cryptic
narrative of a high schooler who is sent on an existential journey after he
escapes death from a falling jet engine and learns that the world has just over
28 days before it ends. In that time, Donnie fends off the torments of being a
teen -- a testy older sister (Gyllenhaal’s real-life older sister, Maggie),
concerned parents (Mary McDonnell and Holmes Osborne), overbearing teachers
(Beth Grant), mild flirtations with a new female student (Jena Malone) -- while
trying to figure out, in some ways, how to save the world.

“That was a movie that was more about the psychological
journey of adolescence and the confusion of it all,” Gyllenhaal tells ET. And
while it featured a cast of fresh-faced young stars, Donnie Darko was a far cry from the popular teen films -- many of
which were about high school romance, parties and sex with pies -- it followed.
Instead, it was about existential angst, a topic that didn’t scream box office
hit at the time.

MORE: 'Dope' and the 13 Best Teen Films Since 'Mean Girls'

Opening just over a month after Sept. 11 in the shadow of
the 1999 Columbine High School massacre, a film featuring a jet engine crash
and a high schooler with violent tendencies was met with little fanfare,
despite the critical acclaim it received. “We were facing an uphill battle,”
Kelly says, citing a cultural climate not open to this type of story. “This
movie just needed to take its time to marinate and it needed to be discovered,
I guess. That's the path it was meant to take.”

That path included a limited theatrical run -- which did
recoup its $4.5 million budget -- before eventually finding an audience five
months later when it was released on DVD. Within a couple of years, Donnie Darko had become a cult classic,
landing on Entertainment Weekly’s
list of 50 Best High School Movies and developing an online fandom that
includes filmmaker Kevin Smith, who even provided commentary on a 2010 special
edition Blu-ray. Now, a 4K restoration version of the film is back in theaters
-- on more screens than its original theatrical run. “I’ll take the slow burn
over the quick flame any day,” Kelly adds with satisfaction that the film has
become somewhat of a phenomenon, if a late bloomer. 

Newmarket Films

For many, Donnie Darko
was discovered on the shelves of long-lost video stores or during Friday night
basement viewings. In places like the East Village in New York City, it was
screened at midnight to growing crowds. It was passed along by word of mouth from
friend to friend and, later, expounded on Reddit and shared obsessively on
Tumblr.

While its narrative may be confusing to some, it proceeded
an appetite for complex storytelling on shows like Battlestar Galactica, Lost and
HBO’s The Leftovers. Duval likens it
to an episode of The Twilight Zone. “People
can revisit it and discover new things each time they watch it,” Kelly says of
the narrative that sustains multiple viewings while also sharing a similar
emotional weight with other teen films like Friday
Night Lights
and The Perks of Being a
Wallflower
.

Gyllenhaal may have been just a bug-eyed young actor who
hadn’t quite grown into the brooding leading man he is today, but the talent
and promise -- shared among a cast of future stars -- was there. “The performances
were good,” says Seth Rogen, who, like Ashley Tisdale, Joss Whedon regular Fran
Kranz and Orange Is the New Black’s
Jolene Purdy
, was acting in his first feature film at the time. (Rogen played
one of the high school bullies alongside Phantom Planet frontman Alex Greenwald,
who is now engaged to Brie Larson.)

MORE: Jolene Purdy Goes From 'Chut Up' Girl in 'Donnie Darko' to 'Orange Is the New Black' Breakout

In fact, Kelly credits the younger cast members -- particularly
Gyllenhaal, his sister and Malone -- for making him a better director. “They
were, in many ways, more experienced than I was,” admits Kelly, who was fresh
out of the University of Southern California, helming his first feature film. Maggie
and Jake had grown up on sets, while Malone could already name-check Susan
Sarandon, Julia Roberts and Jodie Foster as co-stars. (It should also be
pointed out that Donnie Darko counted
Drew Barrymore, who was also a producer, E.R.’s
Noah Wyle, Oscar-nominated Mary McDonnell and Patrick Swayze among its adult
cast, providing an added gravitas that so many teen films -- ahem, The Hunger Games, Divergent and The Maze Runner franchises -- employ
now.)

And over time, Donnie Darko
became part of the collective consciousness for a generation of fans. “It was
something special. It was such a seminal film for [fans] when they were
younger,” says Beth Grant, who played the overbearing Kitty Farmer, coach of
Sparkle Motion, and who believes that it’s a coming-of-age ritual for fans, who
then pass it along to younger siblings.

“I’ve seen it as a rite of passage,” Gyllenhaal says,
sharing Grant’s sentiment. “At a certain point in different people’s lives,
[they] are like, ‘I remember watching.’” Even Amy Adams, Gyllenhaal’s Nocturnal Animals co-star and a former
teen star who got her start in another teen cult classic, Drop Dead Gorgeous, recalls discovering the movie through her
brother. “He was like, ‘Amy, you have to see this film. It’s so good,’” the
actress says.

MORE: Jena Malone Talks Unconventional Childhood and Growing Up With 2 Moms

As to why it still resonates today, those involved have almost
as many theories as there are about the meaning of the film. For Gyllenhaal and
Grant, it’s largely rooted in the rite of passage that’s now being passed down
to younger viewers discovering the movie in the 15 years since its
release.

For Purdy, who played Cherita Chen, commonly known as the
“Chut up” girl
because that was her only line of dialogue, it’s the ways the
film connects with a viewer. “Even if you watch it 15 years later, it can hit
you differently than the first time you watch it. And that’s genius,” she says.

Donnie Darko also
doesn’t pander. In the same way the teen film wasn’t about sex and parties for
Gyllenhaal, for Wyle, it’s like Christopher Nolan’s Memento in that it requires viewers to exert some effort to
decipher its meaning. “They stand alone because they don’t really give a sh*t
if you understand them or not,” he says.

And in some ways, it’s also aspirational. Duval thinks of Donnie Darko as a superhero story.
“[Art] should trigger something in you that becomes a catalyst for something
greater, and Donnie Darko has that,”
he says. “We all want to be that person who saves the world. Wouldn’t you, if
you could save everybody?”