By Antoinette Bueno
3:00 AM PDT, April 14, 2012
Is Aisha Tyler a hottie with a body, or are the feathers on this dress too gaudy?
1 / 11
Aisha Tyler
Getty Images
Is Aisha Tyler a hottie with a body, or are the feathers on this dress too gaudy?
Scarlett Johansson
Getty Images
Does Scarlett Johansson's dress fit her like a glove, or does this Versace gown deserve no love?
Emily Blunt
Getty Images
Does Emily Blunt's unconventional Carolina Herrera dress pop, or are you distracted by the backwards-looking top?
Debby Ryan
Getty Images
Is the Disney darling looking totally cute, or should this dress get the boot?
Noomi Rapace
Getty Images
Can Noomi Rapace pull off wearing all white, or is her stark ensemble a sorry sight?
Ashley Judd
Getty Images
Is Ashley Judd the epitome of class, or is this dress missing some sass?
Freida Pinto
Getty Images
Is Kanye's Givenchy leopard jacket rad, or an example of when high-fashion goes bad?
Paula Patton
Getty Images
Does Paula Patton's dress have the magic touch, or is she hamming it up too much?
Charlize Theron
Getty Images
Did Charlize come out to the Prometheus premiere strong, or is this Stella McCartney dress all wrong?
Cobie Smulders
Getty Images
Is Cobie Smulders' Donna Karen dress so hot it makes you sweat, or does it look like a glorified fishing net?
Tops & Flops: The Week in Fashion
Getty Images
The week in fashion featured a couple of parties and the big Avengers premiere, kicking blockbuster red carpet fashion into high gear. Which celebs' styles made you drool, and who looked like a fool? You decide!