Jimmy Fallon Didn’t Know He Dated Nicole Kidman

by Philiana Ng 10:30 PM PST, January 06, 2015
Photo: NBC

Jimmy Fallon almost dated Nicole Kidman back in the day. Wait, what?!

Kidman appeared on Tuesday’s Tonight Show to promote Paddington, and took a trip down memory lane, reminiscing about their first meeting all those years ago. Through a mutual friend, a then-single Kidman went over to Fallon’s apartment to hang out. What he didn’t know at the time was that she was open to more than just a friendship.

WATCH: Nicole Kidman Explains Marrying Keith Urban After Dating For Only a Month

“I just remember I liked you,” the now-married 47-year-old actress recalled of their first encounter, which had high-end snacks like corn chips, saltine crackers, brie cheese and leftover Chinese food. “Wait… what?” a surprised Fallon said in response, later exclaiming: “Did I date Nicole Kidman?! Was that a date?!”

To further embarrass Fallon, Kidman continued her recollection of their pseudo-date. “You didn’t talk. You didn’t say anything. You were like ‘Hey, mm, mm, mm,’” she said. “So I was like, ‘Okay… so…’”

WATCH: Nicole Kidman Dishes on Keith Urban's Love Letters

And that was it for Fallon, who took that as his cue to leave.

“We weren’t meant to be, right?” Kidman said.

“I can’t believe I dated Nicole Kidman… this is unbelievable!” a flustered Fallon later said, though Kidman heartily disagreed.

Kidman is now married to American Idol judge Keith Urban and has four children, while the 40-year-old Tonight Show host is wed to Nancy Juvonen and recently welcomed his second daughter via surrogate.

Watch the rest of the nine-minute interview for more on why she had previously never appeared on Late Night or Tonight Show.

Can you believe Nicole and Jimmy were almost an item?! We want to hear your thoughts in the comments below, and don’t forget to use the #ETnow hashtag!