What made the day so special is that the Sept. 5 ceremony in the Catskills transformed the two into a real life fairy tale. Santino and Hershberg met during the Broadway production of Cinderella
in 2014, according to the New York Times
. Fontana, 33, was ending his contract with the play as Prince Topher, a role that earned him a Tony Award nomination, while Hershberg was just coming on as an ensemble member and understudy. Before Santino departed the production, he shared the stage with his bride-to-be for three weeks in a scene where they danced.