Miss USA, Olivia Jordan, was the second runner-up in the Miss Universe pageant and, like Miss Colombia, admitted to ET that she too thought Harvey was making a joke.
"Well, Steve came back out after [Miss] Colombia was taking her walk as the new Miss Universe, and [he] came out and said that he made a mistake, which was shocking!" she explained. "I was standing with Pia and I turned to her and I said, 'I think you are Miss Universe!' But she didn't know. We didn't know how to react."