ADVERTISEMENT













ADVERTISEMENT

The New 'American Idol' Controversy

The New 'American Idol' Controversy
Copyright 2008 Fox / FOX

ET has the latest...

"American Idol" isn't just for amateurs anymore. According to USA Today, there are a number of contestants in this season's final 24 who've had recording contracts in the not-so-distant past.

KRISTY LEE COOK was once signed with BRITNEY SPEARS' production company, MICHAEL JOHNS' band signed with MADONNA's Maverick label, until they were dropped. And CARLY SMITHSON recorded with MCA. Her debut album made $2 million, but she was dropped for poor sales.

But "Idol" executive producer NIGEL LYTHGOE insists no rules are being broken, saying contestants are just not allowed to currently be under contract. "We're looking for 'great,'" he tells the paper. "And, yes, those people in all likelihood have had dealings with the industry before."

Posted February 18, 2008 7:28:00 AM
See All: American Idol tv

E-Mail | Print | | rssDiggdel.icio.usTechnoratiBlinklistFurlReddit


John Travolta and Kelly Preston's Daughter Makes Acting Debut in 'Old Dogs'
Nov 09, 2009 12:04 AM (PDT)
 
A Bruised Donny Osmond Still has the 'Dancing with the Stars' Trophy in Sight
Nov 09, 2009 12:02 AM (PDT)
 
Taylor Swift Blows Kiss to 'Twilight' Star Taylor Lautner During 'SNL' Monologue
Nov 08, 2009 02:26 PM (PDT)
 
ADVERTISEMENT
  • StylistAnya: In times square- thousands of Insider fans watching the panel. What a sight! Wow!
  • StylistAnya: Tune in to THE INSIDER this week to see the most fab coats, gloves, scarves and more! It's time for WINTER FASHION!
  • BradBesseyET: In the wake of the Ro-Kelli split, we're happy that R Family Vacations will sail on with gay-family vacations - www.rfamilyvacations.com
  • StylistAnya: Have a fashion question? Style emergency? Just go to theinsider.com and click on "Ask Anya" I will answer your questions!
  • BradBesseyET: Golden Girl Hospitalized! Rue McClanahan is recovering from heart bypass surgery performed yesterday in New York. Speedy Recovery Rue!!!

Catch Hollywood's brightest stars out on the town!

View Star Sightings Gallery

Do you think your fave celeb's style is super sweet or totally beat?

View Hit or Miss Gallery

See whose glamorous style is turning heads around town!

View Glam Squad Gallery

See First Lady Michelle Obama's fabulous fashions within the first 100 days and more!

View the Michelle Obama Fashion Gallery