It seems fourth time was the charm for Nick Viall, as he finally got engaged on Monday's season finale of The Bachelor.
While the 36-year-old businessman was proposing to his "future," Vanessa Grimaldi, his "past," Andi Dorfman and Kaitlyn Bristowe were having a girls night -- with a few other famous members of Bachelor Nation.
Dorfman, who was the first to reject Viall's proposal -- though she popped up on his season for a little heart-to-heart -- poked fun at the "historic" night in an Instagram snap.
"Say whaaaaat?!? #historical @kaitlynbristowe @whitb624 @carlywad," she wrote alongside a snap of herself hanging out with Bristowe, Whitney Bischoff and Carly Waddell.
Bristowe, who chose to give her final rose to Shawn Booth instead of Viall on her season of The Bachelorette, posted a similar shot of the girls hanging out.
"Name a more basic squad," she captioned the photo. "I'll wait. #historical @andi_dorfman @whitb624 @carlywad."
Jen Saviano, who was dumped by Viall on the season finale of Bachelor in Paradise after professing her love for him, posted a simple message alluding to what could've been.
"True that. Stay positive, choose wisely," she wrote alongside a message reading "You're always one decision away from a totally different life."
While Viall's relationships with his exes haven't always been sweet, the women he sent home on The Bachelor seem to have a much different impression.
ET caught up with new Bachelorette Rachel Lindsay at the "Women Tell All" taping last month, where she said seeing Viall again was "bittersweet" -- and revealed that she "missed" the friendship that they had.
See more in the video below.