A "bitter jury" -- as Michaela Bradshaw and Andrea Boehlke described to ET -- voted Sarah the winner.
"Nobody wants to go out and make their family, their friends, their profession look bad, and so the first time I played, that weighed heavily on me. In order to come out and be successful, I had to let that go," she said after being named the winner. "I was given the right of way by everybody and I just came out guns a-blazing because the gates were open for me to do whatever I had to do knowing that they know who I am. And in fact, they beat me down for not being that the first time."
"It was really nice to have their blessing to come out and play this way, even though I hurt a lot of people," Sarah added. "It's not easy to watch back. I'm very proud of the game I played. I'm not proud of the way I treated people."