Entertainment Tonight ET Online ETOnline.com

Given the basic setup of NBC's Love in the Wild (two women are vying for the affections of one man, while competing as a team for rewards), you knew heartbreak was coming. But who would have ever guessed it would hit one of the contestants this quickly?!?

VIDEO - Host Jenny McCarthy Previews Love in the Wild

In an ETOnline exclusive sneak peek from tonight's all-new episode, Jesse gets real with Tara and reveals she is not his first choice to play this game with. A revelation that might have stung less if, as Tara tearfully admits, they had not already been "intimate" with one another.

RELATED - Jenny McCarthy vs. Jim Carrey

Watch the action unfold tonight on an all-new episode of Love in the Wild, airing at 10 p.m. on NBC.