The Pretty Little Liars mid-season three finale featured a reveal of massive proportions as Toby was unmasked as a member of The 'A' Team!
The moment not only came as a surprise to fans, but also to the actors as well since two alternate reveals -- It's Caleb! It's Paige! -- were filmed to help keep the secret.
Now, for the first time, ETonline can exclusively present those unaired moments, which are also featured on the upcoming season three DVD. Check out their turns above, and keep watching to hear the cast recall their reactions to Toby's unmasking!
Pretty Little Liars: The Complete Third Season hits DVD on June 4.