14 Stars Who Appeared on 'Are You Afraid of the Dark?' Before They Were Famous

Elisha Cuthbert (1996)

Elisha started her stint on Are You Afraid of the Dark? as "Young Girl" in "The Tale of the Night Shift" with Entourage star Emanuelle Chriqui. A few years later, she became a regular member of The Midnight Society, appearing in 24 episodes and the TV movie.

Also in this gallery

You might also like

Around the Web