Many of the fan creations poked fun at Christopher Walken's less-then-exuberant dancing…
While some people just wanted to see Walken fly around on wires like he did in the iconic music video for Fatboy Slim's "Weapon Of Choice."
Some pointed out the ridiculousness of Peter Pan Live!'s creepy crocodile…
But the horrifying crocodile didn't cause nearly as much confusion as what appeared to be a dead maid in the Darlings' closet.
Toward the end of the show, Peter Pan (Allison Williams) landed on the deck of Hook's ship while yelling, "Peter Pan, the avenger!" And there was no shortage of people who thought that was weird.
Some memes really need no context at all.
What did you think of Peter Pan Live? Sound off in the comments and tweet #ETnow.