"It was weird saying our own names. That was kind of fun, then Sheryl [Underwood] made me cry," host and executive producer Sara Gilbert said. "She's so emotional that just made it all the more sweeter."
The nomination acted as the perfect welcome back present for Sara, as this was her first day returning to the show since giving birth to her son Rhodes.
The other hosts were still in disbelief from the good news.
"Maybe it didn't feel real because we were announcing it," Aisha Tyler said. "It was a nice surprise."
The Talk wasn't the only show reveling in their Emmy nods. ET also picked up a nomination for Outstanding Entertainment News Program (the category ET won last year), along with The Insider!
"I'm kind of like, 'Huh?'" ET's Kevin Frazier said. "This is incredible! It's an amazing moment, but I want to go and jump up and down with the team over there! We got to go celebrate. We have to have a party!"
Sheryl had the same mindset -- already thinking ahead to the award show parties.