Surprise! Suvari didn't divulge the exact date she wed Hope, but in October 2018, she did reveal to Us Weekly that "third time's the charm." The American Woman actress noted, "It's great. I'm really happy. We're happy," before going on to tell a few reporters about the ceremony. “It was very intimate. It was very beautiful,” she said. “I had my closest friends with me. It was very meaningful. After all these years, sort of having ups and downs, it’s very nice just being settled, especially at this point in my life." The pair met while filming the 2016 Hallmark movie, I'll Be Home for Christmas, which Suvari starred in and where Hope worked in the art department. The American Beauty star was previously married to Robert Brinkmann from 2000 to 2005 and Simone Sestito from 2010 to 2012.