“Fake #tbt to fake high school sweetheart, for fake set photo with the very real @elizabethbanks. #og#badombres #whiteturtlneckanddenimpoppedcollarsosweetdudeyeahiknow #baxter,” Theroux captioned the glamour shot.
In the pic, he’s got a mullet and braces, while she’s rocking a feathered hairdo with thick bangs.
No, these two weren’t real-life high school sweethearts, but they did star in 2005’s The Baxter together. In the comedy, they played exes who reunited right as Banks’ character was getting ready to get married.
In real life, of course, Theroux is married to actress Jennifer Aniston and Banks has been married to film producer, Max Handelman, since 2003.