Alley and Chmerkovskiy formed a close bond in the ballroom when they danced together on both season 12 and season 15 of Dancing With the Stars, but the 36-year-old dancing professional later revealed that he and Alley had a major falling out.
"I thought we had a great relationship," Chemrkovskiy told host Andy Cohenwhen he appeared on an episode of Watch What Happens Live in 2014, "And if it was something else or not, I don't know. But I got a message that now that I'm associating with other people that she can't be associated with, I am no longer to be spoken with, and sorry, but that is what it is ... but I still think the world of her and I wish her the best."
Chmerkovskiy added that he believes Alley's faith in the Church of Scientology might have had something to do with the demise of their friendship. "She stopped getting along with me," he laughed. "I think the world of her. I'm not judging people by their religion. ... I'm Jewish, and you know, I don't really believe in science fiction, but whatever. We had a great relationship."
But the Look Who's Talking star is no longer fixating on past dancing feuds. In fact, Alley admitted she's not even watching DWTS this season. "There's another show that's in competition with [DWTS] that I've sort of gotten hooked on: The Voice," she said.
"This is why I like The Voice: They're creative, and they're nice, and they're supportive, and they validate everyone whether they're good or bad," she gushed. "I just love that vibe of following power and validation to artists. I think it's so valuable to them! Other shows that have competitive singing and stuff like that -- It's just catty and I don't like that."
When asked if she missed preparing for those elaborate DWTS dances, the 64-year-old actress was quick to disagree. "I don't miss the rehearsals at all!" she said with a laugh. "Again, I was so out of my element. It was so inhibiting .. But you don't really realize how hard you're worked when you do that. It's pretty phenomenal.
"I'm shocked that people don't die on the show," she added with a laugh. "I was considering myself like, 'Am I going to be the first one that dies on Dancing With the Stars?' Because it's so physical, it's crazy!"
Alley may not have died on DWTS, but there's no telling if she'll survive season two of Scream Queens!
Scream Queens airs Tuesdays at 8 p.m. ET/PT on Fox.