Noting that she returns to work next week, Rachel went on to say she’s been “groomed for this” when it comes to keeping her secret.
Kimmel tried to crack the determined attorney, subjecting her to a lie detector test and even picking her final three. The late night host selected Eric and Brian and declared Peter the winner.
WATCH: 'Bachelorette' Rachel Lindsay: 14 Things to Expect About Her Groundbreaking Season
But he also quipped, “They never work out, you know that, right?”
“I would love to be the first! I would love to prove you wrong,” Rachel replied.
For more from The Bachelorette
, watch the clip below!