Much to the delight of fans, Applegate’s former co-star, Katey Sagal (who played her screen mom, Peggy Bundy, in the '80s series), made a cameo.
Sagal portrayed Judy’s incarcerated mother, and the show’s creator, Liz Feldman, told TVLine she could be back in season 3 -- and possibly even share the screen with Applegate.
“Thanks you for all the messages about my appearance on @deadtome,” Sagal tweeted. “Here is a shot from the episode.”
Viewers were thrilled with the fun cameo, with many taking to social media to share their joy.
“It was a wonderful surprise,” tweeted one fan. “I screamed, ‘I LOVE HER. SHE IS A PRO AT BEING A BADASS MOM!’ My roommates weren’t so enthused. They’ve never been exposed to your other roles other than Pat from Smart House. ?”
It was a wonderful surprise. I screamed, “I LOVE HER. SHE IS A PRO AT BEING A BADASS MOM!” My roommates weren’t so enthused. They’ve never been exposed to your other roles other than Pat from Smart House. 😅
The second season also featured the return of James Marsden, who, in a fun twist, plays the twin brother of Judy's dead ex, Steve Wood.
Feldman recently told ET that the idea of Marsden returning as a twin only came about thanks to the actor jokingly suggesting ways for him to remain on the series following Steve's death.
"He’s just a great human being and wonderful to have on set, and he and I just really hit it off," Feldman explained. "I received the most incredibly lovely e-mail from him at the end of last season after the show had premiered and people seemed to like it. And he wrote me an e-mail joking around, saying, 'Is there any way Steve could survive a traumatic brain injury and drowning?'"
"I just started laughing when I read [the e-mail] 'cause I just thought that was funny," she continued. "I was like, 'Well, that's a bridge too far for me. I don’t want to suspend reality so far that we don’t recognize it anymore.' But I called him immediately and I was like, 'Would you be interested in coming back if there was a way to do that?' And he said, 'Yeah!' I started pacing around the house and was like, 'How would l do that?' And the idea of him playing his own twin popped into my head."
She also dished on the season's shocking cliffhanger, which saw Jen confess to killing Steve. Feldman admitted that pressure was high to live up to season 1's massive season ending, and that she hoped all the unanswered questions would help secure a third season of the show.
"You always want to leave threads dangling so that you have something to answer in season 3," she said. "And, also hopefully you’re enticing your network or your streaming platform to keep the story going for another season."
"I always start with the beginning, middle, end -- the tentpole moments throughout," she added, about already having a third season storyline sketched out. "And then I rely on the fact that I work with incredibly talented writers, many of whom are smarter than me who are going to come up with even better ideas than I will. I have a rough sketch and everybody really comes in, colors it in and brings it to life."
See more reactions to Sagal's Dead to Me cameo below.