1 / 11
Are you impressed with Mariah Carey's post-baby body, or is this red dress straight-up shoddy?
Do you hate that Jessica Alba looks almost unrecognizable in this dress, or would you consider it a fashion success?
Do you love Gwyneth Paltrow in sparkling green, or are you going blind from all that sheen?
Can the beautiful Immortals star do no wrong, or do you wish she would come out more sartorially strong?
Does Demi Lovato's fuchsia dress glow, or given her age do you wish the neckline wasn't so low?
Has Carrie Underwood come a long way from her simple American Idol days, or do you wish she would switch-up her fashion ways?
Does Blake Lively look great in classic black and white, or should she have worn something a little more bright?
Does Emma Roberts make this Versace for H & M jumpsuit look wonderfully wacky, or is just tacky?
Are you feeling Taylor Swift's over-the-top train, or should she have gone with something more tame?
Does the sexy Modern Family star look super-classy, or do you wish she would have gone with something a little more sassy?
Tops & Flops: The Week in Fashion
The week in fashion featured a fun-filled Country Music Awards and an A-list Versace for H & M event, but which outfits were horrible and which looked heaven-sent? You decide!