Tops & Flops: The Best & Worst of the Oscars

Leslie Mann: A navy wonder, or a fashion blunder?

Ellie Kemper: Is her copper gown worth a million bucks, or is it worse than that universally panned Charlize Theron movie Aeon Flux?

Virginia Madsen: Too plain, or right as rain?

Melissa Leo: Sparkling pajamas, or better than winning a trip to the Bahamas? 

Jane Seymour: Hottie in red, or time to put this look to bed?

Missi Pyle: Miss thang, or not enough bling?

Meryl Streep: Going for the gold, or just too bold?

Glenn Close: Is her gun-metal gray gown totally tough, or not enough?

Kate Mara: Looks like it's falling off, or better than winning a bake-off?

Anna Faris: Beauty in black, or totes wack?

Jennifer Lopez in Zuhair Murad: Never looked better, or worse than breaking a chain letter?

Tina Fey in Carolina Herrera: Is this number a classic design, or past its prime?

Shailene Woodley: A '70s-inspired disaster, or a style master?

Melissa McCarthy: A glowing goddess, or lacking fashion prowess?

Kristen Wiig in J. Mendel: Too understated, or top rated?

Sarah Hyland: Kind of blah, or makes you wanna stand up and go "rah rah rah!"?

Viola Davis in Vera Wang: Is this apple green dress the apple of your eye, or does this choice make you wanna cry?

Busy Phillips: Is her gathered dress bit bland, or just grand?

Octavia Spencer: A demure delight, or a bit too uptight?

Jessica Chastain: Too ornate, or just great?

Maya Rudolph: Has the royal touch, or just too much?

Lea Thompson: Too much glitter, or a red-carpet winner?

Judy Greer in Monique Lhuillier: A striped sensation, or fails to cause elation?

Rooney Mara in Givenchy: Kind of an odd pick, or more exciting than a hat trick?

Rose Byrne in Vivienne Westwood: An unhappy choice, or makes you rejoice?

Berenice Bejo: A perfect fashion kiss, or a total miss?

Milla Jovovich: Is this Fifth Element winning in white, or a scary sight? 

Penelope Cruz in Armani Prive: Not your fave, or better than time-traveling to 1998 and going to a rave?

Natalie Portman in Vintage Dior: Vintage vixen, or a look that needs fixin'?

Sherri Shepherd: Is it odd that Sherri Shepherd's bra is showing, or is The View co-host simply glowing?

Gwyneth Paltrow in Tom Ford: Does it look like she is going to take flight in this caped number, or is she cool as a cucumber?

Michelle Williams in Louis Vuitton: a coral stunner, or a total bummer?

Cameron Diaz in Gucci: Ravishing in nude, or yuckier than eating dog food?

Emma Stone in Giambattista Valli: Too much like Nicole Kidman's 2007 Oscar dress, or a total success?

Stacy Keibler in Marchesa: Golden goddess, or is this leggy lady being a bit too modest?

Angelina Jolie in Versace: A red-carpet win, or a style sin?

Sandra Bullock in Marchesa: An ill-fitting design, or totally sublime?

Take a look at the best and worst of the 84th Annual Academy Awards.