By Antoinette Bueno
3:00 AM PDT, May 5, 2012
Is January Jones' Mary Katrantzou dress beautifully bold, or does it make her look old?
1 / 11
January Jones
![](https://www.etonline.com/sites/default/files/styles/640xh/public/slides/121501/set_january_jones_jkempin_143808974_pix.jpg?width=1024&quality=80)
Getty Images
Is January Jones' Mary Katrantzou dress beautifully bold, or does it make her look old?
Carrie Underwood
![](https://www.etonline.com/sites/default/files/styles/640xh/public/slides/121501/set_carrie_underwood_143485664_pix.jpg?width=1024&quality=80)
Getty Images
Are you feeling Carrie Underwood's country style, or do you find it vile?
Elizabeth Hurley
![](https://www.etonline.com/sites/default/files/styles/640xh/public/slides/121501/set_elizabeth_hurley_120430_slovekin_143610544_pix.jpg?width=1024&quality=80)
Getty Images
Does Elizabeth Hurley still got it, or should she tone it down a bit?
Jennifer Lopez
![](https://www.etonline.com/sites/default/files/styles/640xh/public/slides/121501/set_jennifer_lopez_mbuckner_143610048_pix.jpg?width=1024&quality=80)
Getty Images
Are you feeling the snake on her neck, or is this look a total wreck?
Kate Hudson
![](https://www.etonline.com/sites/default/files/styles/640xh/public/slides/121501/set_kate_hudson_slovekin_143534997_pix.jpg?width=1024&quality=80)
Getty Images
Is Kate Hudson's purple sequin number totally stunning, or should her stylist take off running?
Chloe Moretz
![](https://www.etonline.com/sites/default/files/styles/640xh/public/slides/121501/set_chloe_moretz_143812933_pix.jpg?width=1024&quality=80)
Getty Images
Is Chloe Moretz's floral Dolce & Gabbana dress all the rage, or a little old for her age?
Lea Michele
![](https://www.etonline.com/sites/default/files/styles/640xh/public/slides/121501/set_lea_michele_120501_aerodriguez_143653780_pix.jpg?width=1024&quality=80)
Getty Images
Does Lea Michele look white-hot in a mini, or does it make her look a little too skinny?
Heather Morris
![](https://www.etonline.com/sites/default/files/styles/640xh/public/slides/121501/set_heather_morris_120501_aerodriguez_143653836_pix.jpg?width=1024&quality=80)
Getty Images
Kooky and rad, or just really really bad?
Eva Mendes
![](https://www.etonline.com/sites/default/files/styles/640xh/public/slides/121501/set_eva_mendes_fbrown_143706914_pix.jpg?width=1024&quality=80)
Getty Images
Is Eva Mendes' plaid dress beautifully ladylike, or should it take a hike?
Scarlett Johansson
![](https://www.etonline.com/sites/default/files/styles/640xh/public/slides/121501/set_scarlett_johansson_merritt_143683966_pix.jpg?width=1024&quality=80)
Getty Images
Are you loving Scarlett Johansson in mixed prints, or can she take a few fashion hints?
Tops & Flops: The Week in Fashion
![](https://www.etonline.com/sites/default/files/styles/640xh/public/slides/121501/set_kate_hudson_heather_morris_pix.jpg?width=1024&quality=80)
Getty Images
The week in fashion featured some highs and serious lows, but which stars stood out, and which ones need new clothes? You decide!