Tops & Flops: The Week in Fashion

The week in fashion featured the glamorous Great Gatsby premiere in New York City, but which star's bad style do you pity? You decide!

Did Great Gatsby star Carey Mulligan leave the red carpet competition slain, or is this red dress way too plain?

Did Nina Dobrev upstage even Carey, or does her dress choice leave you wary?

Is Kelly Osbourne's halter mini dress flattering on her curves, or is her purple updo getting on your nerves?

Is Isla Fisher's floral gown a perfect fit, or does the sheer bottom totally kill it?

Does Zooey Deschanel always get her signature hipster style just right, or could she do without those tights?

Does Zoe Saldana's edgy ensemble have your full support, or is this skirt a little too short?

Does Hayden Panettiere look the bomb, or does her yellow gown feel a little too "prom"?

Does Olivia Wilde always look super-chic, or is this frumpy dress hiding her perfect physique?

Did Marisa Tomei show up properly dressed for an event, or does she look like she's wearing a tent?

Does Julianne Hough's dramatic look smolder, or is this dress meant for someone much older