Music Who Covered Carey's 'Christmas' Best? By Jarett Wieselman 8:08 AM PST, December 24, 2012 Vevo While never an underperformer, it's safe to say that Mariah Carey's All I Want For Christmas Is You became infinitely more popular following it's rousing inclusion in 2003's Love Actually. PHOTOS - Sexy Celebrity SantasSince Olivia Olson smashed the song in Richard Curtis' new holiday classic, it's been covered everywhere from Glee to the Today show -- even Mariah herself has re-released a version she recorded with Justin Bieber. PHOTOS - Stars Sit on Santa's LapBut which cover is king? Take a listen to all the options below and then weigh in on which version of All I Want For Christmas Is You is the biggest gift of all! Mariah Carey's 1994 Original Shania Twain's 1998 Cover Olivia Olson's Cover From Love Actually Miley Cyrus' 2007 Cover John Mayer's 2008 Cover Amber Riley's 2011 Glee Cover Mariah Carey & Justin Bieber's 2011 Deut Mariah Carey's 2012 Late Night Acoustic Cover Carly Rose Sonenclar's 2012 X Factor Cover Demi Lovato's 2012 Christmas in Washington Cover WHICH IS YOUR FAVORITE? VOTE BELOW!