The Bachelor couple chose the French and Italian bistro, Landmarc, in New York City's Columbus Circle for their first date, and owner Marc Murphy, who is also a judge on Chopped, told The Insider that the two looked "very much in love" while dining at a "little private table in the corner."
"They seemed to be quite affectionate. They seemed to like each other. That's a good thing," Murphy recalled. "They just went through a long process finding out who they were going to be with and it seems to be working so far. It looked like they were very happy together."
Of course, the date included champagne, a little red wine and candlelight, in addition to a delicious multi-course meal. "They ordered, to start, a roast pepper soup and a chopped salad," Murphy noted. "Afterwards, they had the lamb chops, which they kept raving about."
For dessert, Murphy sent over five mini treats that included cotton candy. He says the couple didn't leave until around 11 p.m.
Higgins, 27, told ET on Tuesday that he was excited to "show off" Bushnell, and that he did! The couple happily posed for a few pics with other restaurant patrons and fans during their night out. "When they left, it was very funny. There was probably about 30 young ladies outside waiting for them to take pictures and they were really really gracious with everybody," Murphy said. "I heard from one of the little teenagers ...she said she was in her pajamas and got dressed and came over here to see if she could see her come out of the restaurant."
Higgins was certainly head over heels for his fiancee when speaking to ET. "She's a beautiful person who I can't wait to share my life with and show people that I'm sharing my life with her," he gushed. "I think that's the part that I am most excited for."