Twelve all stars gave it their all on Dancing with the Stars Monday night, but one unlucky pair didn't quite make the cut.
To kick off elimination night, leaderboard champs Sabrina Bryan and partner Louis Van Amstel took to the dance floor for an encore performance of their high-scoring quickstep. Spanish singer Placido Domingo (alongside season 14 runner-up Katherine Jenkins) and pop sensation Cher Lloyd helped ease the tension during finals on Tuesday, but ultimately one couple would get the DWTS boot.
Related: Deja vu for Gilles Marini on 'Dancing'
Joey Fatone with partner Kym Johnson, Kelly Monaco with partner Val Chmerkovsky, and Helio Castroneves with partner Chelsie Hightower were revealed to comprise the bottom three, but in the end, Joey and Kym were given their leave from the competition.
"Everybody had a good time here," said Joey, who took the defeat with a smile. "I had fun, that's all that matters."
Video: Sabrina Bryan Recounts Dangerous 'DWTS' Rehearsal Mishap
The remaining eleven all-star couples will have their work cut out for them next week. Two dancing duos will get cut on Tuesday in a dreaded double elimination round.
Dancing with the Stars: All Stars returns next Monday night on ABC.