The first guest of the night was Watch What Happens Live host Andy Cohen, who chatted with Mayer about the halftime show and his rekindled romance. "It was unbelievable," Mayer said of Perry's performance, admitting that he watched the game from the stadium's family box. "And I think the whole thing about the sharks, everybody wants to talk about the sharks because it’s just something everyone can grab onto because not everyone feels comfortable walking around saying that Katy Perry was amazing."
Going on about the sharks, he added, "So they use the sharks as kind of, 'Guys, love the sharks.' It's like, you have nothing bad to say about the performance, do you? 'No, I don’t.' Because if they did, you'd hear about it."