"We thought she might be a little heartbroken," said another. "She was probably so depressed that she didn't come in."
In fact, Ripa may take the rest of the week off. A source says she "is pissed" because she was unaware of Strahan's deal to leave the show for Good Morning America until after shooting Tuesday's Live! episode -- the same day that the news became public.
Saturday Night Live alum Ana Gasteyer filled in for Ripa on Wednesday, which a source told ET was a last-minute decision. The actress was apparently called after 10 p.m. on Tuesday and asked to appear.
According to our source, Gasteyer was under the impression that Strahan's exit would not be addressed on the show Wednesday but that the 44-year-old Super Bowl champ changed his mind just minutes before going live.
Upon initially discussing the news about his move to GMA, Strahan neglected to mention Ripa, but circled back later in the program to acknowledge his cohost of the past eight years.
"I didn't want to say it earlier, but I really want to thank, of course, Kelly Ripa, because Kelly welcomed me here and I've learned so much from her," Strahan said on-air. "She's just been an amazing influence on me, and this has truly changed my life to be here with her."