Muniz and Carson -- who came into the finals as the underdogs after being in jeopardy multiple times throughout the season -- performed two dances on Tuesday's finale.
They kicked things off with a Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides-themed Argentine tango set to "Angelica" by Rodrigo y Gabriela, a recreation of their near-perfect Disney Week routine, which earned them a 29 out of 30. This time, the scores were flawless and they earned a 30.
Muniz and Carson's second dance of the night was a foxtrot/tango fusion set to "Without You" by Avicii. While Carrie Ann Inaba was effusive with her praise, Bruno Tonioli and Len Goodman weren't as convinced, and the couple earned a 28.