The self-proclaimed Penn Badgley stan was gushing about the You actor during an episode of The Drew BarrymoreShow Thursday when he gave her the surprise of her life and joined the broadcast for a virtual appearance.
"Is this where I say something?" Badgley asked Barrymore and her Drew's News panel -- which includes fellow Badgely super fan, actress, Casey Wilson -- sending the group into a fit of excited screams and laughter.
The talk show host literally fell head over heels for the actor, landing on her head and over her desk and as newspaper pages when flying, littering the set.
"We love you," Barrymore gushed of her and Wilson's undying love for the Gossip Girl alum. "I can't believe we're talking to you, this is so crazy."
"I can't believe I'm talking to you," Badgley quipped.
The surprise was given to the duo courtesy of Wilson's Bitch Sesh: A Real Housewives Breakdown podcast co-host, Danielle Schneider, who told the ladies she wanted to give them "something big."
"I wanted to give you something big, so I decided I need to give you, You, and by You, I mean Penn Badgley," Schneider revealed.
"I was worried we were going to summon weird people to our lives because we kept talking about why couldn’t we be loved the way you love," Barrymore told Badgley of her adoration for his You character, Joe Goldberg, a serial killer who more often than not ends up killing his love interests.
"Why didn’t you put me in a glass box and starve me and leave me from the world," Wilson added. "And I wish you would stand outside my window and care about what I was thinking and feeling," Barrymore continued. "Kill me Penn, kill me dead," Wilson joked.
While Badgley said that there's "many reasons" why those things can't happen, he couldn't help but feel humbled by their ecstatic reaction to his on-air surprise.
"But honestly, I’m really honored and humbled that, I mean this is a genuine reaction and…it’s very touching," he gushed.