"I came home at six in the morning," Sarah recalled. "[Wyatt] is passed out on top of Eric. They looked like a couple of frat boys with their shirts off. A bottle of milk is in the middle of the bed ... Wyatt's got milk stains on his mouth. I'm like, 'What happened?' There's no covers on the bed. It's like a full-out war happened."
While Eric admitted that he knew Sarah was the one "pretty early on" in their relationship, Sarah joked that she wasn't as easily swayed.
"It took me about five years," Sarah kidded. "When he proposed I was like, 'Hmmmm... Not really sure.'"