It was a Felicity reunion on Jimmy Kimmel Live.
Keri Russell and Scott Speedman followed up Russell's Hollywood Walk of Fame ceremony with a late-night appearance, where they opened up about playing on-screen love interests, Felicity Porter and Ben Covington, on the WB drama from 1998 to 2002, and the short-lived real-life romance that followed. In fact, Speedman recalled being a "disaster of a boyfriend" -- and Russell agreed!
WATCH: Keri Russell Has 'Felicity' Reunion at Hollywood Walk of Fame Ceremony, Shares PDA With Matthew Rhys
"It was a big deal," the Animal Kingdom star recalled of Russell's headline-making pixie cut in season two. "But we were actually dating at the time, and I had been such a disaster of a boyfriend up until then, and I knew I had to put on a good show, and I was going to see her and her new haircut."
"I was like, 'Come on, man, you gotta bring it home. You gotta do it.' And I got to work, and she turned around the corner and my face sort of froze in a half panic, half smile situation. I just did not pull it off, and you called me on it," Speedman, 41, said with a laugh. "It was a chia-head sort of vibe to it. Yeah, chia pet."
"There was a chia pet vibe," Russell, 41, agreed.
While Felicity's hair was a major deal in 1999, it was the pair's romance that Kimmel couldn't get over. "Let's go back to the disaster of a boyfriend," he teased.
WATCH: Remembering Felicity, 15 Years After the Series Finale
"Young 20s is called disaster of a boyfriend," Russell explaining, refusing to divulge more at Speedman's request.
"Not much has changed," he confessed.
As for whether the pair will reunite again onscreen for a Felicity reboot, Speedman said he "really [doesn't] think so."
"Some people are on really high class shows," he joked of Russell's starring role on The Americans. "I'll do it in a heartbeat. I'll be at Lifetime in no time."
FLASHBACK: Keri Russell on Felicity Fame -- 'Everyone Kind of Wants a Piece of You'