While Timberlake stayed firmly in the Team Samoas camp due to his love for coconut, he left it up to his Instagram followers to reach the final verdict.
"Samoas vs Thin Mints... FOOD FOR THOUGHT. Double tap for DOUBLE SAMOAS. Comment for Thin Mints," he instructed in the caption.
As of Friday morning, the post has more than half a million likes and nearly 14,000 comments, indicating that Samoas may be the reigning favorite.
Unlike Timberlake, Jason Momoa's favorite type of Girl Scout cookies are Trefoils. When ET spoke to the actor last year, he reacted to one Girl Scout using his name and photos to retrofit her Samoas cookies to be "Momoas," in honor of the Aquaman star.
"I love Girl Scout cookies, I was waiting to get some free ones. I’d love some," he said. "I want the shortbread -- and then you put those in the freezer and that’s the best way."
"I just want my shortbread cookies!" the movie star added, while his wife, Lisa Bonet, joked, "I think he just wants his cut."
Jennifer Garner is a celeb that loves Girl Scout cookies so much so she'll sell them! Check it out below!