"That was so cool! To have John Wesley Shipp and Mary-Margaret [Humes] here, who played my mom and dad on Dawson's Creek, sitting together," Van Der Beek told ET's Keltie Knight after the show. "It was just awesome. They had great seats, as well they should. Yeah, I love them!"
Humes took to Instagram to share some sweet photos from the evening with Shipp, her former on-screen husband.