The premiere episode broke up the contestants into two groups, with four contestants in each group, and each of the four paired off in a head-to-head singing duel. Group A saw The Butterfly face off against The Egg, and Thingamajig face off against The Skeleton. Meanwhile, Group B pitted The Rottweiler against The Ladybug and The Tree against The Ice Cream.
After some epic performances, revealing clue packages and a lot of random, arbitrary guesses from the panel of "detectives" -- including Robin Thicke, Nicole Scherzinger, Ken Jeong and Jenny McCarthy -- two secret stars had to unmask and go home.
The first star to get the ax this week was The Egg. After a clue package that included a whole lot of references to the Olympics and figure skating, the panelists actually managed to guess who was under the over-easy fedora: Olympic ice skater and commentator Johnny Weir.
The next contestant to get the boot was The Ice Cream, who dropped his cone and revealed his true identity: pro-gamer and internet star, Tyler "Ninja" Blevins.
Jenny excitedly screamed, "My Kids are gonna love this!" Ninja also pointed out that the multi-colored streamers in his package were a reference to him being a streamer, and that the karate references were a nod to his moniker.
This means we've still got time to figure out the famous alter egos of The Butterfly, Thingamajig, The Skeleton, The Rottweiler, The Lady Bug and The Tree.
Competing next week, fans will get a chance to see the next batch of singers face off, and share some new, hopefully, helpful clues.