Nikki goes on to read the card from the 35-year-old former reality star and it only makes her like him more!
"I think my house is haunted. My wine keeps disappearing when I'm the only one home. Happy Halloween," Nikki reads aloud to Kathy, Brie and her brother-in-law, Daniel Bryan. "This gift has nothing to do with Halloween, but I thought the card was appropriate. Here's a little something for your breakfast and for your creative thoughts. Enjoy!"
It turns out Peter sent Nikki "every kind of black licorice," which she says is "actually like the sweetest thing."
"I am a huge, like, lover of black licorice. Just like my wine, I'm very picky about it. But, because Peter didn't bring my favorite licorice last time, he shipped out every type of brand of black licorice to me," Nikki gushes in the confessional. "That was just the cutest, sweetest thing ever. Like, I have to give it to Peter, he's really smooth."
"I love things like this that are extremely thoughtful," she adds later. "That means a lot to me... Maybe there will be a second date."
"Brownie points, Peter," Brie exclaims. "... It was sweet."
Though Daniel seems to like Peter, he does ask, "All you have to do to get a second date is send you $12 worth of black licorice?"
"He's extraordinarily tall and good looking," Daniel amends. "I was almost attracted to him."
"It was great," Nikki tells Brie before she reluctantly leaves her twin's house when she realizes that Brie was sleeping.
"I'm kind of disappointed right now because I just wanted to talk to my sister about the date, to tell her how it went, but Brie doesn't want to talk to me," Nikki laments in the confessional. "All I know is it's awkward right now and I think it's time for me to go to bed. It's a little bit of a buzzkill I'm not gonna lie."
"It was so awkward and I totally got drunk," Nikki admitted on the show.
"Here I am having this first date and all of a sudden I look to my left and it’s, like, two camera crews and I’m like, ‘Oh my god, this is so weird,’” she added. "I didn’t even want to flirt because it was just so weird and awkward.”