Does 'Bachelor' Peter Weber Really Not Know His Own Ending? Breaking Down the Possibilities

Peter has boasted his season finale won't be spoiled, but that hasn't stopped fans from trying.

All good things must come to an end -- and the same is true of Bachelor seasons. 

Peter Weber's finale is officially here... but we still have no idea how his "roller coaster" of a season will wrap up. Both Peter and host Chris Harrison have teased that fans won't see this finale coming, with the half-Cuban Bachelor going as far as to boast that his ending will be the first unspoiled one in years.   

"This season will take you on a roller coaster ride like no other, and right up until the end when Peter and I sit down and have to have a very tough heart-to-heart -- actually a couple of them that final week, it really is unlike any season that we've had before," Chris previously told ET. "When you have a Bachelor like Peter, it's a very raw, emotional ride and the way this ends, no one will see coming."

"You're going to see it all play out," Peter promised. "It'll take your breath away."

Then, on Monday's Women Tell All, Chris said that not even Peter knows how his season ends. But where there are lofty promises, there are also clues, and fans have been hard at work trying to figure out exactly how things will go down. From the theory Peter ends up with a producer, to the possibility of Hannah Brown's return, here are Peter's possible Bachelor endings. 

Theory No. 1: Peter Ends Up With a Producer 

Fans were working overtime putting this one together. The theory that Peter ends up with Bachelor producer Julie LaPlaca emerged when viewers noticed the pair spending time together -- Julie spent New Year's Eve with Peter and his family, and has appeared close with him in several photos. However, Peter falling in love with a producer seems unlikely. 

"Well, I hate to get in the way of a good rumor, so I’m not going to confirm or deny about whether he ends up with a producer!" ABC exec Rob Mills told ET. "I don’t know how we’d ever top that though! But, it is crazy. What we’ve seen about the finale over the years is that the "finale" is really on that night when the show goes live. There’s a lot of craziness, it’s a roller coaster, but I would say even now the roller coaster hasn’t ended, and it won’t end until after After the Final Rose."

Chris, meanwhile, joked to ET that the Bachelor ending up with a producer is a "horrifying" idea, considering the goal of the show is for him to end up with one of his contestants. 

"Julie is an amazing, talented producer. Far be it for me to ruin anything towards the end of the season. But... seems much ado about nothing to me," he said. "Unless I just don't know, which is possible." 

"Clearly that’s not what we’re there to do. That’s not the story we’re trying to create," he explained. "I think it’s a wild story. But maybe it’s just crazy enough to be true!"

And while speaking with ET at the Women Tell All taping, Peter cracked up at a joke Julie was his girlfriend. "[There are] so many theories out there right now. It's kind of crazy to hear," he said, before teasing he doesn't know what will happen. "We'll see." 

(Fun fact: we did see Julie in a shot during the promo at the end of Monday's episode!) 

Theory No. 2: Peter Ends Up With Madison

Fans saw Madison break up with Peter on night one of his season finale, following their discussion about her sharing that she's waiting to have sex until marriage, and Peter confessing that he's been intimate with someone on his season. Even after Madison "left" (Chris teased we haven't seen the last of her), Peter told Hannah Ann he was conflicted about what to do with his final rose.

So, could Peter defy his family's wishes, and choose Madison in the end? We're not putting all our eggs in that basket, but we'll toss a few in. 

At the Women Tell All taping, Peter fiercely defended Madison against criticism about her fantasy suite ultimatum. 

"I don't feel like it was an ultimatum. I don't," he said. "I think it was her doing what I asked every girl to do from the very first night and that was to be honest with me and share what was ever on their heart. And that's what she did."

"Trust me, it made it an insanely incredibly difficult week for me. There's no doubt about that," Peter added. "But I can't fault her for sharing her heart."

When previously asked about Madison and her lack of involvement in drama in the house, Peter admitted to ET he "never got too down and too discouraged because I knew that I was gonna be OK in the end."

As for his reveal that he's falling in love with her, Peter said he was being "honest." "Madison and I had an amazing dinner conversation. That whole date was just very beautiful. She's just very honest with me, and opened up about something that was very important to her, a very important part of her life, and I was very honest with her as well," he shared. "I just feel like at that point, it was just a really good moment for us moving forward and just understanding each other a little bit more. I loved that conversation. I loved my entire date with her."

Theory No. 3: Peter Ends Up With Hannah Ann 

While Peter admitted to being concerned about Hannah Ann's lack of relationship experience early on in the season, they really connected on their first one-on-one date. It's pretty much been smooth sailing for the pair since, so her winning Peter's heart isn't out of the realm of possibility. Another hint she might be the last woman standing? The Venmo theory. 

Peter has a private Venmo account, and so does Hannah Ann. In fact, she's the only member of Peter's final four to have a private account on the money-sharing app. Kelsey, Madison and Victoria F.'s accounts are all set to public. "I did some detective work last week and Pilot Pete is friends with Hannah Ann on venmo. So I’m calling it that she will be the winner," one fan, Spencer Ramer, tweeted in January -- and the theory has since picked up some steam. 

Peter's family would certainly support him picking her -- and he told ET that his relationship with Hannah Ann really took off with their one-on-one date. "I definitely did have some concerns with Hannah Ann from the beginning and that's a very beautiful story here that I think is really going to start to take off between the two of us," he revealed. "There really hasn't been too much of a connection, and it definitely begins here."

And at the Women Tell All taping, Peter opened up about his extreme statement about her during fantasy suites (he called her the most "perfect woman" he's ever dreamt of). 

"Hannah Ann is a very... no one's perfect, but she's very close to perfect. I'm a very passionate dude, and I'm an extremist kind of," he explained. "So, I make these statements and it comes from the heart." 

"That's just who I am," Peter added. 

Theory No. 4: Peter Ends Up With Hannah Brown 

Peter said it in his season premiere -- he might have room for two Hannahs in his life. So, could Hannah make yet another appearance this season, swooping in at the last minute and stealing Peter's heart? Her Dancing With the Stars schedule makes it unlikely (she was shooting the series in Los Angeles when Peter was filming his finale in Australia), but Hannah and Peter didn't deny it was a possibility. 

"I mean, they keep teasing [I might show up again on The Bachelor]. You'll have to keep watching," she told ET in January.   

Peter admitted to ET that during his and Hannah's emotional conversation at the beginning of the season, he was still in love with her. But he also said that he wishes the former pageant queen all the best in her journey to find love.   

"So, let's pretend that yeah we're actually done. Yeah, I would want [her to be the Bachelorette]," he said. "She's an amazing girl, and unfortunately, everyone saw what happened with her relationship and that's unfortunate for everyone involved. She deserves it more than anyone." 

Theory No. 5: Peter Hasn't Chosen Anyone Yet 

Peter's promises that his ending will remain unspoiled have led some fans to speculate that he didn't hand out his final rose in Australia, and that he'll instead make his choice between his finalists on the live finale, After the Final Rose, on Tuesday. Chris' tease that Peter doesn't know how his season will end certainly supports this theory. 

After the Women Tell All taping, Peter confirmed that things "continue to unfold until the very last second. And I don't know when that last second occurred."

The pilot also interestingly told ET that he believes in having more than one soulmate. 

"I've always been a firm believer that the heart wants what it wants, and I think this experience for sure has shown me that there's not just one soulmate out there," he admitted. "I think at some point in my life, I used to think that, and I've definitely been able to give my heart to more than one person." 

When asked if he's with his soulmate now, Peter replied, "I hope so." "I sure hope so," he added. "That'd be great." 

However, when asked in January whether fans will see him follow in Arie Luyendyk Jr.'s footsteps, with things changing after that international final rose ceremony, Peter said that his ending is not "similar." 

"The ending of mine is very unique. So, I'm not saying it's gonna be similar to any of the previous seasons but definitely very unique," he told ET, sharing that his frontrunner had been consistent since week four of the journey. 

"I promise you my frontrunner did not change," he shared. 

Chris also previously told ET that he wasn't sure why Peter was saying his ending wouldn't be spoiled -- which could hint that Peter has indeed made his final pick. 

"He's new at this, so you can't make a claim like that," Chris quipped. "But I know what he's actually talking about, which is, it's a wild finish. It is a season that got turned on its head and is an emotional, dramatic finish."  

Madison and Hannah Ann are all still in the running for Peter's heart -- and he told ET that he's "happy" with how things turned out for him. 

"I'm happy and I followed my heart," he declared. 

The Bachelor's season finale continues Tuesday at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC. ET's Lauren Zima will be recapping the episode on a special live Roses and Rose directly after the episode. Watch ET Live on your Roku, Apple TV or Amazon Fire TV or you can stream on Pluto TV and Samsung TV Plus.


Latest News